Honda Pilot Years to Avoid (and What to Check on a Used Pilot)

By Chris, owner and inspector · October 24, 2026

The Honda Pilot years to be most careful with are 2016 and 2017, which have the most owner complaints filed with NHTSA of any Pilot model year, mostly about the engine and electrical system. Check any 2016 to 2019 Pilot's recall and software-update history before you buy. OTRAM inspects used Pilots in St. Louis for $230.

What the complaint numbers show

NHTSA, the federal vehicle safety agency, publishes every owner complaint by model year. As of October 2026, the 2016 Pilot has 1,719 complaints, far more than any other year from 2005 to 2024. The 2017 (935) and 2019 (919) are next. Most of them are filed under the engine and electrical system.

Complaint counts aren't adjusted for how many cars were sold, so they're a guide to where to look, not a verdict on one car. A well-kept 2016 can be fine and a neglected 2022 can be a problem.

The 9-speed transmission

Honda issued service bulletins for the 9-speed automatic used in the Pilot, including software updates for rough low-speed shifts, hesitation from a stop and harsh shifts under steady acceleration. A later bulletin covers 2016 to 2019 Pilot Touring and Elite models. Ask a Honda dealer to check the VIN for which updates have been done.

On the test drive, feel for hard or jerky shifts, a delay pulling away, and shudder at steady speeds.

Recalls to check

  • Certain 2016 Pilots were recalled because the fuel tank may leak; the fix is a new tank (NHTSA campaign 17V-219).
  • Many 2016 to 2022 Pilots are covered by one or more later recalls. Enter the VIN at NHTSA's recall lookup and make sure every open recall has been done.

What an inspection checks on a Pilot

  • A full scan of the engine, transmission and body modules, including stored and pending codes.
  • A warm road test for shift quality, misfires and vibration.
  • Leaks, fluid condition and the service records for transmission fluid changes.
  • The usual SUV checks: suspension, brakes, tires and the all-wheel-drive system.

Book a used Pilot inspection

A Pilot or Passport is a $230 SUV inspection, anywhere in the St. Louis metro, with the written PDF report the same day. Book an inspection. Buying from out of state? See how out-of-state buyers use OTRAM.

Common questions

What year Honda Pilot should I avoid?
Be most careful with 2016 and 2017, which have the most owner complaints filed with NHTSA of any Pilot year, followed by 2019. Check the recall and software-update history on any 2016 to 2019 Pilot.
Does the Honda Pilot have transmission problems?
Honda issued software updates for shift quality on the 9-speed automatic, including one covering 2016 to 2019 Touring and Elite models. A Honda dealer can check the VIN for which updates have been done.
How much is an inspection on a used Honda Pilot?
$230, with the PDF report the same day.

Related